Optimizing Scar Concealment in Facial Surgery
First of all, scar placement is one of the key steps to concealing scars. Scar placement within the hair, behind the ear, and within natural borders of the skin are important in scar concealment. Scars within the hair are typically designed so that their is no hair loss and that the patients can wear a variety of hairstyles. Behind the ears, can mean a variety of different things. First of all, the surgeon can make a pre tragal (See photo, blue line) or post tragal incision (Green line). The tragus is the little portion of the ear which sticks out from the ear in the very front of it. It does not help in hearing, however, it can be a useful piece of anatomy to cover up a facelift scar. Some surgeons take advantage of this by going post tragal, or hiding the scar behind the tragus. Other surgeons opt for the scar to be located in front of the tragus with a straight line (see second photo, pink line). There are several reasons why the post tragal incision is more desired. First of all, a scar behind the tragus is less visible than a scar in front, due to it being much more difficult to see inside the ear to see this scar. Second of all, our eyes pick up straight lines quickly. By breaking up the scar with an incision hidden in a gentle S format, this is much more difficult to see than a straight line scar.
So why doesn’t every surgeon use a post tragal scar? First of all, it takes more time to perform a post tragal incision. Some surgeons would rather save a few minutes by making a straight line in front of the ear. While the amount of time is a factor, it should NOT be at the expense of scars, especially scars on your face. In addition, the incision must be artfully drawn and then incised behind the ear. It is also more technically difficult to make a post tragal scar look good than a pre tragal incision. Surgeons need to contour the tissues around the ear, sometimes thinning the skin and adding special sutures to create natural contours in this area. Some surgeons may not be trained to create a good looking tragus. While making a scar behind the ear (tragus) may take longer and be more technically difficult than a scar in front of the ear, it has the benefits of better scar concealment.
In addition, the scars are placed around the earlobe. The earlobe is different in patient to patient, with some patients having naturally attached earlobes, versus others having hanging earlobes. A youthful earlobe, is typically small, plump and not attached to the face. The scars around the earlobe are placed in the crease near the ear. When properly executed, the earlobe will retain a similar shape to its preoperative earlobe and similar orientation (earlobe not being pulled forward). In some cases, surgeons can try and stretch the skin and make it tight around the earlobe. Unfortunately, while this sounds good in concept, can lead to a stretched and attached earlobe. The key to a good facelift is lifting the underlying tissue and not trying to have the skin stretch things forward.
Scars are also placed behind the ear in a location called the postauricular sulcus. This location allows the patient the scar to hide within a natural crease. The scar here when properly placed, will set in the crease, making it an excellent location for scar concealment.